Two reports can list Excellent polish and Excellent symmetry even when the diamonds look different in the same setting. Polish describes the finish of the surface. Symmetry describes how accurately the facets and outline follow the intended geometry.
When you are choosing a lab-grown diamond ring, start by identifying what each line on the document measures. Then use a video of the selected diamond to decide whether the differences matter to you. The most useful comparison answers one question at a time, from how the facets are finished to how the stone looks when you turn it.
Read polish as the finish on the surface
Polish concerns the condition of the diamond’s finished surfaces. GIA’s guide illustrates features such as faint lines from polishing, fine scratches and small abrasions near facet edges. Its finish assessment considers the features and how visible they are at 10× magnification. A label such as Excellent therefore describes the surface finish under an examination method. (GIA)
A polish line and a mark inside the diamond are different observations. If you notice a faint line in a close-up, ask whether it was seen on the surface during an examination. A photograph can also record reflections, especially when the broad top facet catches a light source. Follow the mark through a slow tilt and ask for a jeweler’s assessment if its origin matters to your choice. (GIA)
If two candidates carry different polish grades, ask what accounts for the difference and whether the jeweler can point out the relevant area. A close view may help you see why a particular feature was flagged. Ask whether it lies on the large central facet or nearer the rim, where it may be harder to locate in a video. An ordinary view of the ring answers the separate question of what you are likely to notice when you wear it.

Read symmetry as the geometry of the cut
A report’s symmetry grade concerns physical geometry. A grader may consider whether the large top facet, called the table, is centered, whether neighboring facets align as intended, and whether the outline is even for the chosen cutting style. GIA illustrates departures such as an off-center table or misalignment between the table and the bottom tip of the stone. (GIA)
Smooth facets can meet unevenly, and well-aligned facets can have visible polish features. Read each finish entry separately. For an elongated shape, ask to see the whole outline square to the camera. A view taken at an angle or partly hidden by prongs can make the two sides look different, so request a straighter view if one side seems fuller.

Keep optical symmetry and the cut assessment separate
Optical symmetry describes how consistently a pattern of facet reflections repeats. In a round brilliant, a reflective scope can reveal an arrows pattern through the crown and a hearts pattern with the stone table-down. IGI explains that the viewer uses a controlled light environment and that standards for the crispness and consistency of the patterns vary. (IGI)
| Detail | What it addresses | Where to check |
|---|---|---|
| Polish | Condition of the finished surface | The polish entry or professional examination |
| Symmetry grade | Physical arrangement of facets and accuracy of the outline | The symmetry entry |
| Optical symmetry | Repetition of facet reflections under controlled viewing | Stone-specific scope views and the criteria used |
| Overall cut assessment | Combined factors under the issuer’s method | The cut entry where provided, with the issuer’s criteria |
If Hearts and Arrows appears in a listing, ask whether the description comes from the laboratory, the seller or a generic image. Request face-up and table-down scope views of the selected stone, when available. If comparing two stones, ask for the same scope and orientation. Different viewer colors can change how the pattern is presented, and a mounted ring may limit access to the underside. (IGI)
An overall cut assessment considers a broader set of factors. IGI describes different approaches for round brilliants and fancy shapes, with factors beyond finish, such as proportions and shape-specific workmanship. In GIA’s research on round brilliants, observers rated some diamonds without discernible optical symmetry as highly as diamonds with a distinct repeating pattern. If the pattern matters to you, consider it alongside ordinary views of the stone. (IGI, GIA)
Check what the issuer actually reports
Find the issuer, document title, date and report number on the full document for the selected diamond. IGI describes polish and symmetry as finish details on its diamond grading reports. Read the named entries individually and identify the cut grade separately where one is present. The wording beside Symmetry refers to a different assessment from the same wording beside Cut. (IGI)
GIA’s current Laboratory-Grown Diamond Quality Assessment classifies eligible loose, colorless to near-colorless lab-grown diamonds as Premium or Standard. Under its published criteria, Premium requires meeting all the Premium criteria, while Standard can include a mix of Premium and Standard results. Polish and symmetry feed into this classification alongside other criteria. The published chart groups symmetry and cut for round brilliants and lists a separate symmetry criterion for fancy shapes. (GIA, GIA)
This means that a Standard result alone cannot tell you which criterion determined the category. If you want to know what the document establishes about finish, ask which details are stated on that specific assessment. Older documents and other services can have different layouts, so use the document title and date when asking for clarification.
Compare three hypothetical purchases
In the first hypothetical comparison, two round diamonds have IGI reports with Excellent polish. One has Excellent symmetry and the other has Very Good symmetry. The higher symmetry entry identifies a difference in the laboratory’s assessment of the finish. To decide how much it matters for your ring, ask what the jeweler can observe and compare ordinary face-up views. If the second stone’s appearance appeals to you more, record which feature you prefer and under what lighting.
In the second hypothetical comparison, one round diamond has a GIA Standard assessment and another has an IGI report listing Excellent polish and Excellent symmetry. These documents answer different questions. For the GIA stone, ask what details are available beyond the category. For the IGI stone, read the separate cut entry if supplied. View the stones under similar conditions before deciding whether the available reports and the appearance support your choice.
In the third hypothetical comparison, two similarly sized rounds have Excellent polish and symmetry. The listing for the first supplies a face-up arrows image. The second supplies both a face-up arrows image and a table-down hearts image. Ask for the missing table-down view and confirm that each photo corresponds to the stone on offer. If both views are available, compare the repetition of the shapes under matching scope conditions. Then use an ordinary video to decide which stone you prefer in motion.
Ask for video of the selected diamond
Start with a straight-on view that shows the entire outline, then request a slow tilt from that same position. Ask whether the footage shows the diamond described by the report and whether the stone is loose or mounted. If you want to follow a suspected surface mark, ask the jeweler to orient the table the same way in each clip and show where the mark is observed.
For a side-by-side decision, request the same camera distance, background and lighting, and ask for a view in diffuse light such as indirect daylight. A short close-up can show where you should look. A wider view lets you judge the appearance at a scale closer to everyday wear. Ask for an in-person or magnified professional assessment when you need to confirm a particular finish feature. (GIA)

Frequently asked questions
Does Excellent polish guarantee a brighter diamond?
Excellent polish describes the finish assessed by the laboratory. Brightness also depends on how the diamond is cut and how it is illuminated. Compare the actual diamonds under the same light when brightness is a deciding factor.
Does Excellent symmetry guarantee Hearts and Arrows?
The symmetry grade concerns physical features of the cut. Hearts and Arrows describes a particular reflection pattern seen through a viewer. Ask who assessed the pattern and whether both scope views are available for the selected stone.
Can I infer Very Good polish from a GIA Standard assessment?
GIA Standard can combine results that satisfy different levels of its criteria. Check what the specific document says about finish and ask the issuer or jeweler about details you need for a comparison.
Can a magnified video tell me the polish grade?
A close-up can help locate a possible feature. A laboratory polish grade reflects a controlled examination, while video depends on focus, lighting and angle. Ask for a professional assessment if you need to identify a mark.
Explore AIMINIA lab-grown diamond rings and save the exact design and diamond option you are considering. Use the report to compare the details the laboratory assessed, then request a view of the selected stone that addresses the finish or reflection pattern you care about.
Related reading
Cut and brilliance of lab-grown diamonds · Compare and verify gia and igi reports · How to read a diamond clarity plot.